MPLS over PHY vs EFP+BDI/SVI

Testing pseudowires between devices where the core PE to PE interface is configured on either a physical interface (PHY) or on a logical interface (BDI or SVI) bridges via an EFP on the physical interface.

PPPoE is being tested over the pseudowire and a Y means it worked and an N means it didn't.

Original spreadsheet.

+---------------+-----------+-----------+---------+--+---------+-----------+-----------+---------+
| ASR920:       |           |           |         |  |         |           |           |         |
+---------------+-----------+-----------+---------+--+---------+-----------+-----------+---------+
|               |           | ME3800X   | ME3800X |  |         |           | ASR1001   | ASR1001 |
|               |           | EFP & BDI | PHY     |  |         |           | EFP & BDI | PHY     |
| ASR920        | EFP & BDI | N         | N       |  | ASR920  | EFP & BDI | N         | Y       |
| ASR920        | PHY       | N         | Y       |  | ASR920  | PHY       | N         | Y       |
|               |           |           |         |  |         |           |           |         |
+---------------+-----------+-----------+---------+--+---------+-----------+-----------+---------+
| ASR1001:      |           |           |         |  |         |           |           |         |
+---------------+-----------+-----------+---------+--+---------+-----------+-----------+---------+
|               |           | ASR920    | ASR920  |  |         |           | ME3800X   | ME3800X |
|               |           | EFP & BDI | PHY     |  |         |           | EFP & BDI | PHY     |
| ASR1001       | EFP & BDI | N         | N       |  | ASR1001 | EFP & BDI | N         | N       |
| ASR1001       | PHY       | Y         | Y       |  | ASR1001 | PHY       | Y         | Y       |
|               |           |           |         |  |         |           |           |         |
+---------------+-----------+-----------+---------+--+---------+-----------+-----------+---------+
| ME3800X:      |           |           |         |  |         |           |           |         |
+---------------+-----------+-----------+---------+--+---------+-----------+-----------+---------+
|               |           | ASR1001   | ASR1001 |  |         |           | ASR920    | ASR920  |
|               |           | EFP & BDI | PHY     |  |         |           | EFP & BDI | PHY     |
| ME3800X       | EFP & BDI | N         | Y       |  | ME3800X | EFP & BDI | N         | N       |
| ME3800X       | PHY       | N         | Y       |  | ME3800X | PHY       | N         | Y       |
|               |           |           |         |  |         |           |           |         |
+---------------+-----------+-----------+---------+--+---------+-----------+-----------+---------+

---